The difference between being told to do homework and between the choice of doing it if you so desire is two different things. In my perspective I believe that having a choice to do homework is better than being told to do it because I’ve been told to do it and sometimes I don’t do it which I know is wrong will be punished with a lower grade but if you guys give us the option to either do it or not do it then we have a choice to either keep our grade to an an A or drop it down to an F. It really comes down to what you really want so why say having a choice to do homework is the right way.